View Full Version : boats Lund/Crestliner
ret461
09-24-2008, 10:54 AM
Narrowing the field Im wondering any significant differance in the two boats? 18 to 20 foot range. looking for 2003 to 2007. Any input is appreciated. Just to add ive learned more in the past month about equipment/rigging and fishing from this site in a month then wondering blind for years.
I think it comes down to personal preference and maybe the dealer. They're both good boats.
Myself, I'd take a Lund every time. I think the fit and finish is better, I like the layout better, I think they hold their value better, and having ridden in both, I think the Lund rides is better and I konw it's A LOT drier.
Just my $0.02.
Waxy
Manxfishing
09-24-2008, 02:36 PM
There both Alum.
But ones a welded boat and the other is riveted
There both owned by Brunswick
I’d say one is marketed as a higher end boat while the other is more middle of the pack.
While there both nice boats
It's hard to compare the 2 without knowing what models you’re looking at?
ret461
09-24-2008, 04:32 PM
Probably on the line of a prov, single council, used for fishing (with family) and crusing with the big boss and two kids. MUST be able to tow with reasonable comfort long distances (chev 1500 07). 18 to 20 foot. Pretty well set on the Lund for its open space and reputation but want to be sure this is going to be a long term investment. And want somthing a little bigger than i need now. I will grow into it. Also want to be able to handle solo on trips.
stinkycat
09-24-2008, 05:11 PM
My choice would be a Lund, I have never owed a Crestliner and I am sure they are a fine boat.
When I was looking this last winter the Lund stood out for fishability and seemed to be finished better than most.
Also wanted a good dealer and the couple that I narrowed it down to were both Lund dealers and sell loads of Lunds.
lund115
09-24-2008, 05:34 PM
Both are great boats,
Lunds are a little more $, but you pay for quality and the name. Lunds have a few more options, and have the LUND name. You pay a few extra dollars to have that Lund name on the side of the boat(they've earned it over the years)
For a few dollars less, you get a Crestliner, which in my opinion is nothing but a great boat. Just a few less options.
Manxfishing
09-24-2008, 05:43 PM
The Single consoles are nice for fishable space
But the Big Boss might not like all of the wind over there
I think you can add the second console later if needed
The ProV's are very nice boats
They have the double hulls and are a little thicker then the run of the mill alum. boat
Plus they have all of the bells and whistles
It's top of the line in alum.
teamlund
09-24-2008, 06:13 PM
:grin:I love my lund! I am currwntly looking into my 3rd. I now have a 18 ft prov that is for sale. I would also say go with a Dual console. The big boss will be much happier and they look awesome. There will still be plenty of romm for the family. I tow my lund with a 99 f150 and it has a 4.2 L V6 and a manual trans. It has 150k miles. Your truck will pull it around no prob.
I would also agree about the fit/finish being 2nd to none. Fishibility is the best hands down.
:cheers:
teamlund
09-24-2008, 06:40 PM
Ret, I sent you a pm...:happy:
2Labs
09-24-2008, 07:31 PM
The replies you have gotten so far are right on.
I currently own a Lund. I bought it instead of a Crestliner because I felt it was better built and I thought the layout was a bit better as well.
Get the dual console. I sold my old boat because it was a single console and I could not upgrade by adding a second console. Don't make my mistake.
Also, good for you for getting a larger size than you might originally be satisfied with. Most of us didn't learn that lesson and upgraded boats due to "2 foot-itis". Boats "shrink" when you put them on the water!!!
Gooch88
09-24-2008, 08:12 PM
I would agree with the posts thus far, I am a 1900 Pro-V owner (dual bubble...second best thing on it). It is my second Lund, my first was a 18 Explorer SS, it was a nice boat but the Pro-V is killer above all tin boats. If it fits your budget. I can't sing the praises enough...super roomy, super comfy and performance is awesome. If you look at the way Lund's hold there value over all others...that alone is worth it. Also as for easy pulling a 19 footer gets you a tandem axle trailer and if you have ever had a single axle you will soon realize the difference...HUGE difference pulls like a dream...also do your self a favor and avoid the roller trailer blues, stick witha bunk trailer...you will not find a simpler loading boat and trailer...just drive her on and drive away. I have pulled mine with my F150 and F250 of coarse the 250 pulls it like it's not even there but my 150 worked just fine as well.
stinkycat
09-24-2008, 08:27 PM
I would have to disagree with Gooch88 on his trailer issue. I would not go with out a roller trailer. The only blues would be when I get to one of my favorite lakes and not be able to put in because of no rollers. I can load my boat by myself and be ready to drive away in less than 3 minutes once the trailer is in the water. I drive a 1725 Pro Guide with 75 hsp . Never found a lake yet I can not get into. I did find several lakes that would never been in the water with a bunk trailer. With that said I have never owed a bunk trailer but have been with many that have. IMHO
teamlund
09-24-2008, 08:50 PM
Bunk trailer all the way! Cranking up a 17 ft tiller is alot diff than crankin up a 18-20 ft prov with any where from 150 -225 hp and all the goodies... With a bunk trailer it goes on right every time no matter what... Much easier to do by yourself.:bigsmile:
Gilligan
09-24-2008, 09:08 PM
I fish a big Crestliner the 2150 Sportfish and you will not find a more roomy layout for fishing. Though not as spacious they do make the Sportfish in both an 18' and 19'. I considered both Lund and Crestliner and made my decision based on the best dealership I had to deal with. Since being in my Crestliner I would not hesitate to buy another. As far as Crestliner being a wetter ride, I've rode in some pretty wet Lunds. Get a full windshield and you will stay dry.
stinkycat
09-24-2008, 09:21 PM
TeamLund,
I haven't cranked up more than 1-2ft of strap in many years. Usually 1-2"! Power load and hit the road!
teamlund
09-24-2008, 09:29 PM
the last rollwe I had when I loaded it I would have to leave the engine running in gear with high rpms and run up and strap it becasue the boat would roll off if I killed the engine. Some people dont like power loaders especially when I had to strap mine before I killed it. No issues with a bunk.
ret461
09-25-2008, 12:02 AM
I have to say again! The infomation and feed back has been awesome Iv learned ALOT with it, and how much ive missed fishing over the years! Its obvious the lund is the way to go. Been looking at the boats out there on the internet, and will also take a hard look at the dual counsel. Thanks to all
ret461
09-25-2008, 12:17 AM
sent a reply hope you got it.
I have to say again! The infomation and feed back has been awesome Iv learned ALOT with it, and how much ive missed fishing over the years! Its obvious the lund is the way to go. Been looking at the boats out there on the internet, and will also take a hard look at the dual counsel. Thanks to all
Going with a dual console or full windshield is excellent advice, especially if you plan on using the boat as a family boat as well.
I bought my 1900 Pro V as a single console, one trip out with my wife and I was told I either had to sell it or get a second console. It can be done, but it's not cheap - around $1500 and a long wait - so take that into cosideration when you're shopping. You really don't lose much "fishability", and you gain a ton in comfort and storage.
I'm also going to put in a vote for the bunk trailer. Combined with side guides, it's by far the easiest and most dependable loading system, especially if you're going to be using the boat alone. The boat practically loads itself. If the water is too shallow to get your boat on/off the trailer, then the water is too shallow period. There's no way you're going to hand crank a 19-20' Pro V onto a trailer, and nor are you going to get it off in that shallow of water without a major hassle. If you can power load a roller, you can power load a bunk. If you regularly fish lakes with poor launches like that, buying a big Pro V might not be the answer.
Waxy
P.S. Does Crestliner have the equivalent of Lund's SportTrak system? That alone would practically be enough to make me go Lund.
Gilligan
09-25-2008, 12:32 PM
P.S. Does Crestliner have the equivalent of Lund's SportTrak system? That alone would practically be enough to make me go Lund.
Waxy...
Cant say I am real impressed with the Trak system. I helped a friend rig rod holders on his new Lund this spring as he was preparing for a torney on Lake Erie and after seeing how much movement there is in the track when everything is tightened down we decided to mount rod holders directly to the gunnel. The dealer had his gps/finder mounted to the track. I figure that hit the floor the first time he encountered his first 3'er. Might be fine for calm water, or some types of fishing but I would hate to see what would happen to the holder with a big dipsie on it especially if a big fish hits.
Waxy...
Cant say I am real impressed with the Trak system. I helped a friend rig rod holders on his new Lund this spring as he was preparing for a torney on Lake Erie and after seeing how much movement there is in the track when everything is tightened down we decided to mount rod holders directly to the gunnel. The dealer had his gps/finder mounted to the track. I figure that hit the floor the first time he encountered his first 3'er. Might be fine for calm water, or some types of fishing but I would hate to see what would happen to the holder with a big dipsie on it especially if a big fish hits.
I can't say as I've had the same experience. Mine have been rock solid, even in the conditions you describe.
On top of that, the convenience of being able to position everything from fish handling and re-tying tools to cupholders wherever you want them in the boat is simply awesome.
Waxy
stinkycat
09-25-2008, 03:14 PM
I would totally agree with Waxy... Great system!
Hombre Robusto
09-25-2008, 04:10 PM
A buddy of mine pulled Dipsys for four years on rod holders mounted on the trak mounts. Never had a single problem with them.
Mounting
09-25-2008, 04:24 PM
Sounds like a mounting problem to me. Using the proper hardware is critical in order for the system to work as designed.
jawjerker
09-30-2008, 06:21 PM
Are you considering a tiller or a wheel boat??
Jawjerker
ret461
10-01-2008, 05:15 PM
Wheel boat with dual council, going to be a lund probably a pro-v or fishermen. Thanks!
T Mac
10-01-2008, 05:29 PM
Both are great boats,
Lunds are a little more $, but you pay for quality and the name. Lunds have a few more options, and have the LUND name. You pay a few extra dollars to have that Lund name on the side of the boat(they've earned it over the years)
For a few dollars less, you get a Crestliner, which in my opinion is nothing but a great boat. Just a few less options.
You pay for more aluminum (in most models) and more hand labor in the Lund.
The name costs nothing.