could this fish really be 17.8 lbs?
 

I found this picture surfing the world wide walleye web , this guy is claiming this is a 17.8 lb fish, I'm not saying it isnt, Im saying it looks like a common erie 10 pounder...maybe im wrong, what do you think? [url]http://www.walleyehunter.com/charley.html[/url]

could this fish really be 17.8 lbs?
 

I found this picture surfing the world wide walleye web , this guy is claiming this is a 17.8 lb fish, I'm not saying it isnt, Im saying it looks like a common erie 10 pounder...maybe im wrong, what do you think? [url]http://www.walleyehunter.com/charley.html[/url]

RE: could this fish really be 17.8 lbs?
 

I agree. Nice fish, but someone must of had their thumb on the scale on that one...

RE: could this fish really be 17.8 lbs?
 

I agree. Nice fish, but someone must of had their thumb on the scale on that one...

RE: could this fish really be 17.8 lbs?
 

I agree looks like a 9/10lber ,not enough belly on that fish to be 17 lb just my .02 worth .jim

RE: could this fish really be 17.8 lbs?
 

I agree looks like a 9/10lber ,not enough belly on that fish to be 17 lb just my .02 worth .jim

RE: could this fish really be 17.8 lbs?
 

A little short in my book too.

RE: could this fish really be 17.8 lbs?
 

A little short in my book too.

RE: could this fish really be 17.8 lbs?
 

What'd he do with the other 8 pounds missing from the picture?

RE: could this fish really be 17.8 lbs?
 

What'd he do with the other 8 pounds missing from the picture?