Walleye Message Central - Search Results

		Walleye Message Central > Search Forums
Search Results

Page 1 of 18

Last »

Showing results 1 to 25 of 434
Search took 0.05 seconds. Search: Posts Made By: Multispecies Guy

Forum: Canada

01-06-2018, 10:13 PM

Replies: 77

Next year's trip or trips?!

Views: 18,885

Posted By Multispecies Guy

June bowhunt for black bear near Vermilion Bay...

June bowhunt for black bear near Vermilion Bay that will include fishing in area lakes. August trip to Great Slave Lake Lake, NWT for big pike. Sept canoe trip to either BWCA or Quetico.

Forum: General Discussion

12-05-2017, 03:40 PM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

I still favor an AIM format (yet to hear a...

I still favor an AIM format (yet to hear a reasonable downside to it) but what you suggest is probably better than the format under question.

Forum: General Discussion

12-05-2017, 03:39 PM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

No, the rates I cited are from actual scientific...

No, the rates I cited are from actual scientific studies. I cited the studies in an earlier post. No assumptions. Factual stuff as opposed to you lobbing out stuff like tournament mortality is...

Forum: General Discussion

12-05-2017, 09:42 AM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

OK, now we can have a discussion. I’ll ask you...

OK, now we can have a discussion. I’ll ask you this but then I gotta run. Given studies that show tournament mortality rates for weigh-in tournaments of varying percentages but commonly in the...

Forum: General Discussion

12-05-2017, 09:22 AM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Can’t argue on point, divert to another topic. ...

Can’t argue on point, divert to another topic. How about at least one post from you on topic? Mortality—too high? Should AIM be the only DNR approved format?

Forum: General Discussion

12-05-2017, 09:09 AM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

No, I’ve raised a valid concern about tournaments...

No, I’ve raised a valid concern about tournaments that you don’t want to address because, even though you know mortality is a problem, you don’t want to face it. So you constantly try to sidetrack...

Forum: General Discussion

12-05-2017, 08:35 AM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

There are valid points to counter your comments...

There are valid points to counter your comments but that’s off topic. The point is tournament mortality and what should be done about it if anything.

Forum: General Discussion

12-05-2017, 06:46 AM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Update to my OP—-unsurprisingly have not heard...

Update to my OP—-unsurprisingly have not heard back from the tournament hosts/organizers on the issue of fish mortality from the 2017 tournament held in Marinette.

Also recently talked with a...

Forum: Canada

10-29-2017, 10:46 AM

Replies: 11

Fish kill off on Cliff Lake Ontario around 1979/80

Views: 3,666

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Vicinity of Cliff—Cedar is virtually across the...

Vicinity of Cliff—Cedar is virtually across the road from Cliff. Never fished it but have friends who really like it for musky, bass and walleye.

Forum: Canada

09-17-2017, 02:29 PM

Replies: 5

Shoal Lake Fishing Report Sept 9-16, 2017

Views: 1,340

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Differently--not much. Would probably go in...

Differently--not much. Would probably go in early June rather than mid September. I wanted to go the last week in September but the week we went was the camp's last week before closing. Inevitably...

Forum: Canada

09-17-2017, 11:50 AM

Replies: 5

Shoal Lake Fishing Report Sept 9-16, 2017

Views: 1,340

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Shoal is mostly uncharted but a portion is...

Shoal is mostly uncharted but a portion is charted. I still don't trust that it's accurately charted though. There are buoyed travel routes like there are on LOTW. Tim Kobelka of SLL does provide...

Forum: Canada

09-17-2017, 06:05 AM

Replies: 5

Shoal Lake Fishing Report Sept 9-16, 2017

Views: 1,340

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Shoal Lake Fishing Report Sept 9-16, 2017

Fished Shoal for bass/pike. Fished solo and first time on Shoal. Weather for week varied from 55 and light rain to clear and a record 90 degrees. 2 days and part of a third included strong winds...

Forum: General Discussion

08-26-2017, 06:36 PM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Actually I have a good point regarding more than...

Actually I have a good point regarding more than one tournament. The Lake Link link I provided mentioned a tournament on the Bay where 600 fish were killed. I provided stats from studies showing...

Forum: General Discussion

08-26-2017, 01:00 PM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

I was motivated to start this thread based on the...

I was motivated to start this thread based on the 40% figure which was a shock to me. Wanted to know if it was typical, how it compares to bass tournaments and what others thought of it. The...

Forum: General Discussion

08-26-2017, 12:41 PM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Sorry, forgot to address the slot limit issue. ...

Sorry, forgot to address the slot limit issue. Seems to me that on slot limit waters catch, record, release would be the ONLY option. Under no circumstances would I support the DNR waiving any size...

Forum: General Discussion

08-26-2017, 12:34 PM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Thanks, and I agree with you. To be clear, I am...

Thanks, and I agree with you. To be clear, I am not suggesting getting rid of tournaments. I don't care for them but I understand why others do. I realize they are here, in one form or another, to...

Forum: General Discussion

08-26-2017, 10:07 AM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Said I was going to drop out of this discussion...

Said I was going to drop out of this discussion but I feel compelled to comment again. I don't know if it's ego, stupidity or some other character flaw on my part that refuses to let this die but...

Forum: General Discussion

08-24-2017, 04:36 PM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

CustomEyes-- do you see the irony in you talking...

CustomEyes-- do you see the irony in you talking about others making assumptions and then talking about the dead fish you see which you assume are from recreational anglers? As for the DNR, would...

Forum: General Discussion

08-24-2017, 02:24 PM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Exactly, but Burr said he knew of studies so I'm...

Exactly, but Burr said he knew of studies so I'm waiting for him to cite them.
Subjective-- that's part of my concern. The effect of tournies needs to be a known quantity. Many people are saying...

Forum: General Discussion

08-24-2017, 12:39 PM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

I gave the study you cited a quick scan. It does...

I gave the study you cited a quick scan. It does not appear to suggest that tournaments have no impact on a fishery. The opposite actually. They even offer suggestions on ways to improve survival...

Forum: General Discussion

08-24-2017, 12:27 PM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Thanks. I will read that within the next couple...

Thanks. I will read that within the next couple days. My Google search turned up two DELAYED mortality rate studies from walleye tournaments. One was 55% the other showed <2% for one tournament...

Forum: General Discussion

08-24-2017, 12:05 PM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Excellent post. I've heard others mention seeing...

Excellent post. I've heard others mention seeing 100+ boats within sight even on a non-tournament weekend. Some will view that as a sign that the fishery is strong and there's no problem. Others...

Forum: General Discussion

08-24-2017, 11:57 AM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

Actually I AM interested. I would appreciate you...

Actually I AM interested. I would appreciate you passing along those studies. Thanks

Forum: General Discussion

08-24-2017, 10:52 AM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

You could have just said that from the start........

You could have just said that from the start.....

This time of year, yes 40% would be an anticipated mortality number in my experience.

Since you admittedly feel negative about tournaments,...

Forum: General Discussion

08-24-2017, 09:31 AM

Replies: 132

Tournament mortality...too high??

Views: 10,787

Posted By Multispecies Guy

I suppose it's only natural for both parties in a...

I suppose it's only natural for both parties in a confrontation to think the other party is a jerk. think

Showing results 1 to 25 of 434

Page 1 of 18

Last »

Forum Jump

All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:51 AM.