Puppet Minnow and the Jigging Rap

[ptm]

For all the guys that have used both are they pretty similar in action or do you think one has some advantages the other doesn't?

[KPKyllo]

I think they are basically the same and both work equally well for me. I do prefer the color selection of Jigging Raps but the Puppet Minnows are less expensive.
I use both.

[darrelbarrows]

i have also used both and have caught fish on both, in my opinion 1 is not better than the other, it depends on the fish and what they want, not what looks good in the tackle box.

[Jfraze10]

If different action is what your after buy a shiver minnow or two. I personally prefer the Raps but the shivers had good results open water fishing this summer.

[T Mac]

I have caught walleyes on all 3 - Raps, Puppets and Shivvers, this fall.
Being on fish is the deal

[Chad]

Puppet Minnows work just fine. The past two years I had to prove that to myself and actually out fished my partner with them. That sealed it for me. Very similar actions. Puppets were jut on sale for $4 at Scheels this past weekend.